Oasis says Green Day ripped them off

[Ali]

Well I just dont think that is going to happen, unless you run into the on the street, or something like that. I think by liking them, then thats all they care about. They are about their music, and as long as you like it, then maybe thats all that matters to them eh?

I mean I am sure music has changed alot of peoples lives, but I personally wouldnt go out of my way to make the band know that.

[Jaccoby]

Oh my god. Calm it down with the insults.

[Pan.]

You guys seriously need to fuck off. You're both brainless idiots.

Well I just dont think that is going to happen, unless you run into the on the street, or something like that. I think by liking them, then thats all they care about. They are about their music, and as long as you like it, then maybe thats all that matters to them eh?

I mean I am sure music has changed alot of peoples lives, but I personally wouldnt go out of my way to make the band know that.

What I meant by thanking them is by somehow doing something for them....like promoting their music and maybe even writing a letter to them expressing how thankful we are. That's all.

[penutt]

You guys seriously need to fuck off. You're both brainless idiots.

[Pan.]

Asshole.

[Ali]

You guys seriously need to fuck off. You're both brainless idiots.

What I meant by thanking them is by somehow doing something for them....like promoting their music and maybe even writing a letter to them expressing how thankful we are. That's all.

Maybe you should start a fanclub??.....uhhh...

[nessa1416]

atleast i don't like mcr

Pwned! I don't think you can get a better burn.

--

So because I think that this guy has a right to free speach I'm not a true Green Day fan? Sorry, I wasn't informed I had to worship them like Gods.

Noel is entitled to say whatever the fuck he wants about whoever the fuck he wants, even if it's your precious Green Day. Not like they haven't dished out the disses over the years.

We all know that Green Day didn't copy Oasis, but that doesn't mean that Noel can't question it. I think everyone forgets who it was that said "question everything". :/

[Amanda]

I can't believe 24 hours later and its the same people spamming this up with arguments again.

[Pan.]

Maybe you should start a fanclub??.....uhhh...

I wanted to, but I changed my mind.

Eh...I guess I'll just show my appreciation by buying their merchandise and listening to their music frequently for now.....I'll probably do something big for them someday...

[penutt]

I can't believe 24 hours later and its the same people spamming this up with arguments again.

i was'nt here yesterday

I wanted to, but I changed my mind.

Eh...I guess I'll just show my appreciation by buying their merchandise and listening to their music frequently for now.....I'll probably do something big for them someday...

don't you have a life?

[Ali]

I wanted to, but I changed my mind.

Eh...I guess I'll just show my appreciation by buying their merchandise and listening to their music frequently for now.....I'll probably do something big for them someday...

[nessa1416]

Perhaps you don't understand that sure, they like playing music to us, but they like our money even more.

[Ali]

I wanted to, but I changed my mind.

Eh...I guess I'll just show my appreciation by buying their merchandise and listening to their music frequently for now.....I'll probably do something big for them someday...

thats kinda creepy in a way, sorry.

[nessa1416]

don't you have a life?

You're my new hero

[...Whatsername...]

Not like they haven't dished out the disses over the years.

Reminds me when they made fun of Nickleback That was funny.

[Pan.]

So because I think that this guy has a right to free speach I'm not a true Green Day fan? Sorry, I wasn't informed I had to worship them like Gods.

Noel is entitled to say whatever the fuck he wants about whoever the fuck he wants, even if it's your precious Green Day. Not like they haven't dished out the disses over the years.

Sometimes I wonder why you people misinterpret what I say. You immediately flame me or criticize me... don't I have the right to voice my opinion? Please, it's a fucking free country. And if I like MCR, so what? You all have to respect that as I respect your taste(s) in music. FYI: Everyone has different tastes in music.

I see Green Day differently from how you guys see them. No, not like "Gods," but more like heroes. I don't expect anyone in this forum to love Green Day as much as I do, and I never said worship Green Day. All I was trying to say is that I really want to show Green Day how much I care about them in any way I can. As lame as it may sound, I defend Green Day because I love them, and they have earned a very special place in my heart. It just hurts me when people (not just Noel) talk shit about them.....

Nessa1416, I never said you weren't a true fan. All I was trying to say is that I defend Green Day because I feel like it's the right thing a true fan should do, but that's just my opinion.

[nessa1416]

Reminds me when they made fun of Nickleback That was funny.

Yeah, that's what I was thinking of.

I mean, I really don't like Nickelback, so I don't care that they made fun of them. But at the same time, Oasis fans may not like Green Day. It's a two-way street you see...

It's really not a big deal. People are getting so upset, but if one is such a huge fan, you have to realize that there's going to be a lot of people who dont like them, and sometimes those people are going to be other artists.

It's really not that big of a deal!

Sometimes I wonder why you people misinterpret what I say. You immediately flame me or criticize me... don't I have the right to voice my opinion? Please, it's a fucking free country. And if I like MCR, so what? You all have to respect that as I respect your taste(s) in music. FYI: Everyone has different tastes in music.

I see Green Day differently from how you guys see them. No, not like "Gods," but more like heroes. I don't expect anyone in this forum to love Green Day as much as I do, and I never said worship Green Day. All I was trying to say is that I really want to show Green Day how much I care about them in any way I can. As lame as it may sound, I defend Green Day because I love them, and they have earned a very special place in my heart. It just hurts me when people (not just Noel) talk shit about them.....

Nessa1416, I never said you weren't a true fan. All I was trying to say is that I defend Green Day because I feel like it's the right thing a true fan should do, but that's just my opinion.

I wasn't dissing your taste in music. Like MCR all you want, I'm not going to stop you. But I hate them, so I'm going to voice my opinion.

If I remember correctly (and I'm too lazy to look it up) you said "forgive me if I'm a true fan and don't want people dissing my heroes" or something like that. I took that as you saying I wasn't a true fan, not that it matters.

And when I went into the "Gods" thing, I wasn't targeting you. There are people who really do think that they're higher beings, the whole "Green Day is my religion" thing. And they arent. They are people like you or me who just happen to be highly skilled at music.

And if I have to respect your taste in music, and you have to respect mine, don't we all have to respect Noel's?

[Pan.]

I mean, I really don't like Nickelback, so I don't care that they made fun of them. But at the same time, Oasis fans may not like Green Day. It's a two-way street you see...

It's really not a big deal. People are getting so upset, but if one is such a huge fan, you have to realize that there's going to be a lot of people who dont like them, and sometimes those people are going to be other artists.

It's really not that big of a deal!

I already know that a lot of people hate Green Day, but why falsely accuse them of ripping other band(s) off? That's just bullshit.

.....Sometimes I don't understand why so many people hate such an amazing band.

If I remember correctly (and I'm too lazy to look it up) you said "forgive me if I'm a true fan and don't want people dissing my heroes" or something like that. I took that as you saying I wasn't a true fan, not that it matters.

And when I went into the "Gods" thing, I wasn't targeting you. There are people who really do think that they're higher beings, the whole "Green Day is my religion" thing. And they arent. They are people like you or me who just happen to be highly skilled at music.

And if I have to respect your taste in music, and you have to respect mine, don't we all have to respect Noel's?

At first I thought you were targeting me when you said that, but I'm glad you made that clear.

And yes, we can respect Noel's taste in music, as long as he shows some respect himself, which he hasn't.

[...Whatsername...]

I already know that a lot of people hate Green Day, but why falsely accuse them of ripping other band(s) off? That's just bullshit.

.....Sometimes I don't understand why so many people hate such an amazing band.

Because some are jealous. Others just don't like them and don't see whats so great about them and their music. And every fan is the same way. Most fans want to defend the people they like to listen to. Hasn't anyone seen the "oH eMM gEEe. Y dU sUm pEoPLe HaiT FeRgIe!!!!!!!!111!!!!" We all have different tastes, we all like different things. They don't know what they're missing, but oh well. Too bad for them.

[nessa1416]

You know, this isn't the first person that has accused Green Day of copying their material. I mean, I don't think they did it, but you really never know...

Noel is just trying to cause shit, as was Brandon. Noel has been a shit disturber for as long as I can remember; him and his brother get into it all the time... it's not like this is going to effect GD.

But I'm going to bed. G'night.

[Pan.]

It won't effect Green Day's career in any way, but a lot of fans will get offended with his [Noel's] comment. I know he has the right to say whatever the fuck he wants, but I just thought that was very disrespectful of him saying "They could not be less kick-ass if they tried."

I mean, I bet there are a few fans out there saying "Damn...Noel is right. GD has ripped them off!" There are just some people whose opinion of a band changes easily when some other band talks shit about them; then there are the true fans, the people that don't give a shit about what other bands say about a band they like (i.e Green Day), like me. I don't care about what Noel has to say, but why can't he get his facts straight before falsely accusing GD of ripping them off? That's what pisses me off.

[Pan.]

Oh, and I apologize if I've offended anyone. My anger really got the better of me, but I think I deserve an apology as well. :/

[allenxtreme]

have you people ever thought that there may be a pattern here? It's not a sudden "everyone hates Green Day" thing, it was gradual and people have a right to vent, I don't think Noel jumped on any bandwagon with the slagging off, have you ever thought that instead of sticking up for Green Day straight away/ maybe you should read, or listen to the people that are "hating" and concentrate on the fact that they could well have a point...or is that too much to ask?

[Ali]

have you people ever thought that there may be a pattern here? It's not a sudden "everyone hates Green Day" thing, it was gradual and people have a right to vent, I don't think Noel jumped on any bandwagon with the slagging off, have you ever thought that instead of sticking up for Green Day straight away/ maybe you should read, or listen to the people that are "hating" and concentrate on the fact that they could well have a point...or is that too much to ask?

I guess we all just have our own opinions on this. No one is ever going to agree on it.... :/

[bat-chen]

have you people ever thought that there may be a pattern here? It's not a sudden "everyone hates Green Day" thing, it was gradual and people have a right to vent, I don't think Noel jumped on any bandwagon with the slagging off, have you ever thought that instead of sticking up for Green Day straight away/ maybe you should read, or listen to the people that are "hating" and concentrate on the fact that they could well have a point...or is that too much to ask?

You got a point there. I read the articles with all the Green Day "hatings" and maybe they don't do it only to

slug Green Day, maybe they saing what there saying cause they truly believe when this, but I still don't disagree with them. they have the right to slug Green Day and I have the right to defend Green Day.