1972 project speculation thread

[billy1986]

Im no insider this has been on YouTube for awhile sounds like Billie….may not be real BUT if this is a real demo I’m pumped 

[Flashback]

As an amateur music producer I feel very triggered when someone compares any work of Green Day to burnt pizza. For most people it's impossible to get even close to the sound that they can create in a studio. They are working their asses off that every single element and instrument of a song fits together, from crafting an amazing guitar tone (which took over years) to trying out a massive amount of cymbals every time so that they don't clash with the guitars in any way or to have three tracks of bass guitar layered on each other without any phase issues. Sure we can hear a difference between the production of FOAM and the production of 21st Century Breakdown, but these differences are on such a high level that we are far away from taking anything as burnt food.

[Flynn]

19 minutes ago, billy1986 said:

Im no insider this has been on YouTube for awhile sounds like Billie….may not be real BUT if this is a real demo I’m pumped 

it's only been up for like a day, how do you even find something like this? my guess that it could be someone else's song but they put AI Billie over the vocals, but it doesn't sound that bad. I mean we are close to an announcement so leaks are possible? I don't have enough info to be certain on anything lol

With how prominent A.I. is I literally cannot be certain anymore 😭

[Insomniac90]

3 minutes ago, Flynn said:

it's only been up for like a day, how do you even find something like this? my guess that it could be someone else's song but they put AI Billie over the vocals, but it doesn't sound that bad. I mean we are close to an announcement so leaks are possible? I don't have enough info to be certain on anything lol

With how prominent A.I. is I literally cannot be certain anymore 😭

Yeah especially with leaks with an unperfect sound

It sounds really like Billie but idk, sometimes not 😂😂 But its very different from what they‘ve done before, not a bad song tbh even if its not Green Day. 

[Flynn]

channel seems to be made specifically with the purpose of uploading this as well

[Mato]

C'mon guys it's not them. Train your GD fan ears.

[Flynn]

Just now, Mato said:

C'mon guys it's not them. Train your GD fan ears.

I am, I usually pick up if it sounds like Billie but it's hard to tell. It honestly does sound like him, again I'm not sure either way lol.

[petros]

Come on now the "owing us something" comment is just silly. 

You can have expectations of a band and don't support them if you don't like them or the music anymore but saying they owe you something is silly.

[Austrian_Insomniac]

37 minutes ago, billy1986 said:

Im no insider this has been on YouTube for awhile sounds like Billie….may not be real BUT if this is a real demo I’m pumped 

This sounds better than gd

[jengd]

I would say not Billie Joe and if it is that would be a huge departure from them.  
Hm, the more I listen the more unsure I am.  It’s very Beatlesque.

[Baro]

56 minutes ago, billy1986 said:

Im no insider this has been on YouTube for awhile sounds like Billie….may not be real BUT if this is a real demo I’m pumped 

Not Green Day. Not Billie's voice for sure

[Flynn]

1 minute ago, Baro said:

Not Green Day. Not Billie's voice for sure

What gives it away for you?

[PluckyJokerhead]

https://vivadeath.bandcamp.com/track/damnatio-memoriae

It's just pitch shifted Viva Death again...

Let's not fall for that twice

[Flynn]

Makes sense

[Insomniac90]

7 minutes ago, PluckyJokerhead said:

https://vivadeath.bandcamp.com/track/damnatio-memoriae

It's just pitch shifted Viva Death again...

Let's not fall for that twice

Now I’m sure it’s Billies 192th side Project, cap 

[DeJennsitized]

Caught up on this thread, you’re all so fucking funny 🤣 looking forward to the 24th!! 

[AlienVisitor]

3 hours ago, billy1986 said:

Im no insider this has been on YouTube for awhile sounds like Billie….may not be real BUT if this is a real demo I’m pumped 

Doesn't sound like a riff Billie would come up with

[jengd]

https://vivadeath.bandcamp.com/track/damnatio-memoriae

them again.  From Flynn on GreenDay.fm

[Little Boy Named Booze]

Viva Death is back!! @That Dude

[JardyOfSuburbia]

On 10/6/2023 at 1:27 PM, dudley dawson said:

I’m in the minority who likes Pacific Daydream, but in any event, check out Bethany Cosentino’s (Best Coast) recent album Natural Disaster. Butch produced the entire thing (minus the last track) and played most, if not all, of the instruments and it sounds BEAUTIFUL. So I don’t think blame for FOAM should be placed fully at his feet.

I like Pacific Daydream as well! Butch has also produced some of my favorite albums from Brian Fallon and Frank Turner. I think FOAM's shortcomings fall more on the band than the producer, but I still like that album.

[nflsbest26]

Can’t believe it’s only been a week since the teaser announcement. Hope within these next 2 weeks we get some more hints! 

[That Dude]

12 hours ago, Banjodewulf said:

this Deep fake is both the scariest and coolest thing i've ever seen 

 

Since Billie did this guest vocal for her, Avril should pay them back tenfold by doing Lady Cobra's part on Nightlife.   

In fact, I've got a guy that makes AI covers for me now.   I might ask him if he can make Mike Dirnt sing Billie's part and then Avril do Lady Cobra's.      OH YEAH! My problem with being a Youtuber is that I actually get too MANY views so I want to make this obomination that will actually get negative views.    Haha.   Remember the Billie Joe deleted scenes from that movie?    Funniest thing ever. 

I have to go listen to Viva Death now.   I'm a fan of theirs simply because of their loose ties to Green Day.   I got all excited because I thought maybe they had a NEW song but it's just from that same album.    Guess we should be prepared for this to happen with the next 12 Green Day records as well.    Next time it will be me doing it and I'll choose the song "Storm" .  Remember this in 2028 when we're on here FREAKING OUT trying to figure when the new album will drop.   

 

 

 

 

 

19 hours ago, DookieLukie said:

I’m going to open a pizza shop and serve burned pizza and say “I don’t owe you anything” when customers complain and then blame entitlement when my restaurant fails.

Pizza is actually a good analogy for Green Day.    Both are made for the masses and you can never go wrong with either one....unless you burn it, I guess.  Green Day fans, please do not burn the Green Day.   You might get high and make That Dude style posts on a forum.    

Some food for thought.   Some people LIKE burned pizza.  I know my girlfriend and I discuss this often.   She's like food burned and I like almost raw, gooey food.   So if there was burned Pizza place, the burned pizza eaters would go there and when the raw, gooey fans went there, they would not be happy.       Yes, this is very interesting anology and there's a good arguement either way.   

I am boycotting Haushinka hard, but other than that one horrific misguided, destructive piece of vile offensiveness - Green Day have been entertaining me proper since 1997.     I almost wanna cancel them over that one song but I am refraining. 

  

[Maddie86]

5 hours ago, Austrian_Insomniac said:

This sounds better than gd

No it doesn't 

[Christian's Inferno!]

27 minutes ago, That Dude said:

Since Billie did this guest vocal for her, Avril should pay them back tenfold by doing Lady Cobra's part on Nightlife.   

In fact, I've got a guy that makes AI covers for me now.   I might ask him if he can make Mike Dirnt sing Billie's part and then Avril do Lady Cobra's.      OH YEAH! My problem with being a Youtuber is that I actually get too MANY views so I want to make this obomination that will actually get negative views.    Haha.   Remember the Billie Joe deleted scenes from that movie?    Funniest thing ever. 

I have to go listen to Viva Death now.   I'm a fan of theirs simply because of their loose ties to Green Day.   I got all excited because I thought maybe they had a NEW song but it's just from that same album.    Guess we should be prepared for this to happen with the next 12 Green Day records as well.    Next time it will be me doing it and I'll choose the song "Storm" .  Remember this in 2028 when we're on here FREAKING OUT trying to figure when the new album will drop.   

 

 

 

 

 

Pizza is actually a good analogy for Green Day.    Both are made for the masses and you can never go wrong with either one....unless you burn it, I guess.  Green Day fans, please do not burn the Green Day.   You might get high and make That Dude style posts on a forum.    

Some food for thought.   Some people LIKE burned pizza.  I know my girlfriend and I discuss this often.   She's like food burned and I like almost raw, gooey food.   So if there was burned Pizza place, the burned pizza eaters would go there and when the raw, gooey fans went there, they would not be happy.       Yes, this is very interesting anology and there's a good arguement either way.   

I am boycotting Haushinka hard, but other than that one horrific misguided, destructive piece of vile offensiveness - Green Day have been entertaining me proper since 1997.     I almost wanna cancel them over that one song but I am refraining. 

  

Would you prefer to eat burned pizza or listen to Haushinka?

[rev]

6 hours ago, billy1986 said:

Im no insider this has been on YouTube for awhile sounds like Billie….may not be real BUT if this is a real demo I’m pumped 

Are we really even entertaining the idea that this is Billie Joe? Seriously? The amount of vibrato in his voice tells me immediately it's not him. The way he's singing...not him. Nothing about this is Green Day at all. This makes FOAM Green Day....look like Green Day, lol...