Leaderboard

Well that was a thoroughly well-reasoned and thoughtful critique that addressed all of his points.

It's the only thing your comments are good for, tbh.

Well since no one else (besides Tom) is defending the beautiful gem that is Macy's Day Parade I suppose I will. It is hands down one of the best songs in their catalog. It doesn't quite match Good Riddance because Good Riddance has a better riff and lyrics that are timeless. But what it lacks in guitar creativity it more than makes up for in it's absolutely beautiful building resonance. The song begins slowly and in a low key then builds gradually with each verse. Accompanied by these ever so faint strings that are just barely noticeable. But they build with Billie's voice. As does the tempo. It all builds together and creates this wonderfully simple and slightly nostalgic feeling. Then I realized what it took To tell the difference between Thieves and crooks A lesson learned to me and you This^ is probably my favorite vocal moment from Billie ever. The run on "you" is spectacular.

St. Jimmy is strong because of how tight it's played on the album. When they play it live it goes a little too fast and it becomes sloppy, which takes a way a lot of the strength and power of the song. Becomes more of a generic fast guitar song, then.

And bingo was his name-o. I usually include this caveat in my obligatory bullet points on why the Trilogy is sub par, but it fails to do anything for GD's sound. If they truly were returning to their pre-concept album days, then you would expect an increased focus on what earned them success, which includes everything that you said. But it doesn't do that. It doesn't advance GD's sound as ALL of their albums from 39/smooth through 21CB had, and it doesn't include much of what made them a successful band to begin with.

Holy shit, I never realized that before. Shows how much I listen to it.

I think that kinda works with the theme of the song though, slowly going crazy with your mind eating away at you.

I'd argue that, at times, Warning is a more politically-charged album than American Idiot. I will never understand the "political sellouts" argument in reference to AI. Warning had plenty of songs with a theme of societal criticism (Warning, Macy's Day Parade, Minority), which in my opinion is what "political" music is all about. It makes for a pretty fluid transition into AI. Their progression as a band isn't exactly surprising. Don't most of these obviously valid points contradict that statement? The defining "Green Day" characteristics (harmonies, bass lines, clever lyrics, distorted guitars) aren't in the trilogy at all, and therefore it is hardly a "return to its roots."

^obviously not a "real fan" -Steven Seagull

Yeah, I don't think they've said anything. Stupid people arguing with false points. Great, now that I watched that one 5sos video, youtube thinks I want to subscribe to every boyband vevo channel. Fuck off ye twats.

But Mr Whirly had a catastrophic incident. Can't you at least try to be nice to him?

So how is that Green Day related?

Brain Stew really needs Jaded to complete it. Together, they're my favorite song on Insomniac.

End of an era :-(

Nope, just calling you out on your low quality Internet posts.

It's funny because all of you are disagreeing with Seagull and saying his opinion is stupid and that he's trolling, yet you keep egging him on and getting all offended. Good Lord, ignore him!

No, cause then we call him out, and get rep from other people that dislike him. Rep is life -Adam

Well, at least you put Rest in the proper position.

This is getting ridiculous. If Steven has that intention of keeping reiterating his opinion with not much depth and certainly with nothing new to say, could we just ignore him? Like, there's been so many pages wasted already. That conversation (if it even deserves to be called a conversation) leads absolutely nowhere.

On the contrary, it's stamped with your butt of disapproval.

You take that back RIGHT NOW. NGFL IS FAB.

I think Nice Guys Finish Last beats it for worst opener.

This entirely. And just the lyrics overall are amongst the best Billie has ever written. Maybe not the cleverest or most complex, but just simple, to the point and utterly fantastic.

As far as I understand a real fan is one who agrees with Steven. I should have a grade in ornithology.

AI (the single) is important. To deny that is simply an individual looking for ways to be controversial. Warning was a commercial flop. The band was on the cusp of retiring. The public simply wasn't interested in Green Day anymore. Then, in the middle of an era where Bush was POPULAR (he got re-elected, btw), Green Day release their first single, American Idiot. The song immediately captured the public's attention, amassing radio play and sales in large quantities. AI was the first GD song to be featured on the Billboard Hot 100, peaking at 61. Bottom line is, the song made an impact. Welcome to a new kind of tension. All across the alienation. This line garnered a lot of praise from critics everywhere. AI served it's purpose perfectly. It got GD back on the map, it captured the public's attention. It made a statement.

No it is not. To me Green Days biggest appeal has always been melodies. Billie is truly gifted at coming up with great melodies. And when a Green Day song has not got a good melody, it cannot be gery good. Thats why personally I don't like songs like St. Jimmy, Take Back, Christians Inferno or yes, Platypus, that much.

I'm gonna go back to that video and set those fuckers straight

A collector bought it on eBay (first, I tried to buy it, but I had to wait for the 'OK' from the credit card holder - my neighbor - but it was too late. Someone bought it first) and then sold it (for more) to me. That's always great, right? I love this kind of people. Buying something they already have and selling it for (in this case double), just to make money and shit on some other collector who's looking for it for years

I find it strange that so many people know that song. Didn't realize it was that popular. Some guy at work told me he hates Green Day except that song. Weird that as a Green Day, it sort of pales compares to other songs, even from the same album.

Seagull is GDCs rep whore pimp

There's one for the quote-mine portion of the sig.

AI is shit trilogy is actually good.

http://www.azlyrics.com/lyrics/joshturner/iwasthere.html I think Todd referred to that version by Josh Turner.

Lmfao

Who's that by?

I think you need to go sit in a darkened room and think a bit about what you have done here.

lol

Misery was good the first few listens, but now I think it just drones on and on.

shenanigans is way better than the trilogy. i'd rather have a 14-song incohesive "album" than three with 37 songs that suck.

Just found this on tumblr, so cute

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EvxPjxmnYVM&index=22&list=PL8BE5FBD73F930092

:wub:

my reaction to: I regret nothing