I had my doubts, too, but after seeing it myself, I have to agree with what everyone has said up here^^
I agree with you Dorie about stepping away from Green Day a bit - when I seperate the two things, it's great for me. I love the album and the music on its own, but then the musical is like another take on it, and I love that, too. It's like looking into someone else's in-depth perspective on what the album means to him, and of course part of that is Billie Joe's (most of it, lol) but added to or expanded is Michael Mayer's. Some of it I've seen in my own head and felt in my own heart, but a lot of it I hadn't before. And I like it.
I was curious as to what my hubby would think after he saw it - he is a Green Day fan and loves their music, but he's doesn't "GET" the whole Green-Day-fan-thing, if that makes any sense, lol. He really liked it a lot, but also said that he doesn't know if people who don't already love their music will love the musical. I disagree because I think their music is so very diverse and easily relatable to many different people. I guess we will see.
And YES Abbey!!! Yes. His arrangement of Before the Lobotomy is just...